| Sound News | Press Releases | Archives | Week In Review | Editorials | Articles |
| Reviews | Benchmarks | Interviews | FAQs |Files & Drivers |
| Early Impressions | Game Guide | Search | Links | Forum | Contacts | ADS |



title_3dss.jpg (8000 bytes)
dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)

Been away for a few days? No better way to catch up on the sound scene than our week in review.

dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)

Please support 3DsoundSurge by visiting our sponsors
dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)
dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)

 

The Week in Review: May 29 - June 4, 2000

Last week's features at 3DsoundSurge

Skywell Magic Sound Live Reviewed
In this review we take an in-depth look at the Magic Sound Live 5.1 sound card from Skywell. This card is interesting thanks its 5.1 analog output and the bundling of WinDVD for a SRP of 99 dollars. The Magic Sound Live uses Fortemedia’s FM801 chip which features support for DS3D, A3D 1.0 and EAX 1.0 using QSound's Q3D 2.0 engine. It also features QSound’s stereo expansion technology, QXpander and 2D-3D. The killer feature as mentioned is of course the 5.1 speaker support which many have been waiting on to play DVD movies using home audio 5.1 systems that are just Dolby Digital ready (that is they don’t include a Dolby Digital decoder but have the inputs for one). As a bonus, with the latest drivers the card also delivers 5.1 support for In this review we will take a look at how the Magic Sound Live performs for playing music, games and DVD movies. While we still have lots of detail for games and music, when it comes to movies we really beefed up our usual testing in order to compare it to true hardware DD 5.1 decoders such as the MidiLand ADS-2000 and VideoLogic DigiTheatre decoder, as well as the 4-speaker down-mixing mode of the Sound Blaster Live and Vortex2. We also tested it with MidiLand's S4-7100 5.1 ready speaker system using games and DVDs and we even give some pointers on how this interesting card might be best utilized. For all the details check out the full review.

 

Last week's sound news

Drivers and bugs

  • New Rio500 Firmware Upgrade
    S3/Diamond has released a firmware update (2.11) to the Rio500 MP3 player. The file date is almost 3 weeks old but I don't think we have mentioned it. New features are Support for 64MB flash cards and finally audible support!
  • The APS 2.0 drivers have been indefinitely postponed
    We usually don't cover soundcards that are only intended for music but considering that the APS 2.0 drivers were supposed to be compatible with the Live and also feature support for DS3D and EAX 2.0 this may be interest to some of you. For those that don't know, E-Mu has talked about the APS 2.0 drivers for quite some time, including letting the public know what features they would include. More than once, the release date has been pushed back and now it looks like they will never be released! Here's the message you get if you mail E-mu tech support asking about them according to a post in the newsgroup:

    The development of Version 2.0 Drivers and Applications for the APS that was unofficially announced on the newsgroup has been indefinitely postponed

    Others have also received the following message:

    E-MU / ENSONIQ would like to apologize for our unofficial statements which were pre-mature regarding Version 2 drivers and applications. E-MU / ENSONIQ will continue to work hard to bring quality products to you, our customers. In the future we will exercise more caution with announcements we make to our customer base.
    Sincerely,
    Todd Shires
    E-MU / ENSONIQ

    If you check out the APS newsgroup on Creative Labs server you will find out that people are not very pleased to hear this. It's probably the worst pr fiasco I've ever heard about when it comes to soundcards. Aureal's delay of EAX drivers is a runner-up in this category. In both cases the issue is not that the drivers they already had were poor. Its the way they promised things within time frames that they were not even close to keeping. Note that in the case of poor driver development, there are certainly many other companies with track records that are much worse.

 

New games, demos, patches and bugs

  • Vampire has gone gold
    Vampire's Lead Programmer Rob Huebner has updated his .plan with the following interesting bit:

    Well, there's nothing more cliche than a .plan that says "We're gold" but since the opportunity only comes along every couple years these days, what the heck. Vampire: The Masquerade - Redemption US release is in duplication and will show up at your local mall/retailer/warehouse store on June 7 or 8th!

    We're busily working on a playable demo and also putting together the "NOD SDK version 1.0" which will document all the file formats and so on. We hope to have a preliminary version of the SDK available by June 7, although some of the tools might lag behind a bit to polish them a bit more for public consumption. More detailed info about the demo content and dates will be forthcoming.

    The SDK will include:

    Embrace editor (modified from QERadiant)
    NOT object template editor
    NOD viewer (standalone 3D model & LOD viewer)
    Documentation for file formats: NOD, NAD, NAM, NAG, NSC, and many others.
    HTML documentation for the CODEX Java API (via JavaDoc)
    Source code for all Java classes and game scripts
    Introduction to using Embrace and other starting documents

    Thanks to everyone who participated in the beta and on our web board during
    development!

    Vampire is expected to support A3D 2.0 and DS3D with EAX. No idea if it will feature wavetracing or what version of EAX it will use. For more about the game and to pre-order you can head over to Gamestop.

  • Sammy Sosa Softball Slam demo
    3DO has released a demo of the DS3D with EAX supporting Sammy Sosa Softball Slam™. I'm not sure what version of EAX it uses but I would guess most EAX games now use EAX 2.0 even though games like Sammy Sosa Softball Slam is unlikely to take advantage of the occlusion and obstruction features. You can grab the demo from 3dfiles where you will also find a short description of the game.
  • Descent 3 1.4 Patch
    If you don't like to use the in game auto update you can download the 1.9 MB Version 1.4 update for the A3D 2.0 and DS3D with EAX 2.0 supporting Descent 3 from 3Dfiles. There are quite a number of bug squashes (many listed on the download page) included fixes for a sporadic sound crash bug, a sound system crash when playing audio taunts in the pilot menu before playing the game and a problem that caused unneeded sounds to not be deleted.
  • Messiah Patch 0.2
    A 3.9 MB patch has been released for the DS3D with EAX and A3D 3.0 supporting Messiah. The only audio related fix listed is various problems with CD music loops have been fixed. You can see the full list of fixes on the 3Dfiles Download Page.
  • wHeretic v0.5a build 9
    wHeretic v0.5a Build 9 as been released. This new release apparently fixes a problem related to the true looping sounds. wHeretic audio support is built with the A3D 2.0 API. For lots more details head on over to the official wHeretic site. BTW in case you don't know, wHeretic is a W32 port of the original Heretic from Raven Software.
  • Matrix for Half Life Released
    If you are looking from some more life out of the excellent A3D 2.0 and DS3D with EAX supporting Half Life then you might be interested in knowing that the Matrix mod for Half-Life has been released. For more details and download info head to the official site.
  • Martian Gothic patch
    TalonSoft has released a patch for the A3D 1.X and DS3D with EAX supporting Martian Gothic. You can find download links and list of fixes at 3dfiles
  • Carnivores 2 v.1.1 Patch
    The v.1.1 patch for the A3D 2.0 and DS3D with EAX 2.0 supporting Carnivores 2 fixes sky problems on some 3D accelerators such as PowerVR, GeForce, Voodoo3, etc. You can grab the 529 KB patch from 3dfiles. Note that the patch info notes that A3D 2.0 and EAX 2.0 support was added but I am pretty sure thats a bring forward from the 1.0 patch released way back in November 99. In fact, everything listed as a fix in the 1.1 patch was listed as a fix in the 1.0 patch and the file size is identical!
  • Allegiance 1.11 Live
    Planet Allegiance reports that the version 1.11 patch for Microsoft Research's DS3D supporting Allegiance in now live on the main servers.
  • Vampire MP3s
    Vampire Vault has posted some new MP3s taken from Nihilistic's gone gold, A3D 2.0 and DS3D with EAX supporting Vampire: The Masquerade - Redemption. No idea if it will feature wavetracing or what version of EAX it will use.
  • Summoner MP3
    There is a new MP3 titled "Carados" available on the downloads page of the official Summoner Website. FYI "Carados" is the soundtrack for the Daily Radar gameplay trailer that was recently released. Summoner is a fantasy role-playing game that is supposed to support A3D 2.0 and DS3D with EAX.
  • New: Sound Control Plus v1.76 (BETA)
    Paul McKnight of Really Effective Software has just released a new version of Sound Control Plus v1.76 (BETA).

    Changes this release include:

    • Fixed - Further On Screen Display speed improvements
    • Fixed - Eliminated most of the grey On Screen Display issues on some setups
    • Fixed - Delay On Processing hot keys on some setups
    • Fixed - Winamp Jump To File window not coming to top
    • Added - Hot Keys for Open Winamp, Open Standard Mixer, Open Options
    • Added - Small volume popup option when single clicking on tray icon
    • Added - Global disable hot key of SCP functionality
    • Added - Option to force Winamp Jump To File window to top
    • Added - General information hot key
    • Added - Hide Tray Icon option

    Sound Control Plus is a freeware replacement Windows Sound Mixer applet which together with most of the features of the standard Windows mixer it also allows you to add hot keys to adjust any combination of your sound mixer volumes. Support to control Winamp with a series of hot keys and an On Screen Display is also included. Supports Windows 95 / 98 / NT4 / 2000 and Millennium-Me. Visit the official website for a full list of features, license and download information.

  • Winamp 2.63 released
    Nullsoft has released a new version (2.63) of the popular Winamp. Nullsoft says this version brings major improvements to Winamp's streaming audio capabilities (such as authentication), better multiple language support, a WMA encoder, more live content in the minibrowser, and a host of bug fixes and improvements. You can grab it from Winamp.com
  • UltraPlayer Version 1.0 Released!
    UltraCo Incorporated announced today the Version 1.0 release of their UltraPlayer™ MP3 Audio Software. The UltraPlayer Version 1.0 media player is available for free download at www.ultraplayer.com. UltraPlayer 1.0 plays MP3, WAV, WMA, CD Audio, and Internet radio streams using what the announcement calls "the highly efficient true-fidelity Neutrino™ MPEG audio decoder". UltraPlayer also supports secure digital music formats via relationships with DMOD (Digital Media On Demand), eLicense, and Microsoft Windows Media (WMA). The media player features a dual-mode, intuitive interface with animated UltraSkins, audio plugins, and 3D visualization modules. For more details you can check out the full announcement.
  • DVD Genie 3.50
    Yet another version of this little tool that allows you to tweak your DVD player has been released. A couple of major changes. One is there is a fix for the Hollywood-Plus 4-Speaker settings to work with the newest drivers and the other is support for 4-speaker downmmix has been enabled for Cinemaster 2000. There are other changes and you can check out the full list here.

Reviews of soundcards, speakers, headphones and MP3 players.

  • E3 report about Santa Cruz
    SysOpt has posted an E3 report where the only audio related bit is about Turtle Beach's upcoming Santa Cruz. One new bit here is that they say the reason Santa Cruz didn't include AC-3 decoding is that it would increase the price with 25%, that is $125 instead of $100.
  • Creative @ E3
    GA-Hardware has written up their account of Creative Labs' E3 presence including some impressions of the upcoming PS2000 virtual Dolby Digital system designed for the PS2. According to the report, the new speakers create a sound field that is almost indistinguishable from a 4-speaker system. I am somewhat skeptical of that but don't doubt that the design of the system and their focus on virtual surround makes them much better than average in that respect. The report also covers the PlayWorks DTT2500, the Nomad II and the 3D Blaster Annihilator 2.
  • CPX Multimedia Ports
    3D Gaming World has posted a review of the CPX Multimedia Ports, an accessory to relocate the common soundcard ports to the front of the PC system (via a unit that fits in the 5 1/4" drive bay).
  • Mission X Space Speakers
    GameSpy has posted a review of the Mission X Space speakers. This is particularly interesting as its the first higher end (£300 or around US$450) amplified system that I have seen using NXT's flat panel technology. One thing I can't quite follow is why the reviewer starts off by stating that "they not only use the newly found NXT technology, but they are also very, very thin, making them a must for serious gamers." I am not sure about you but that is not what I look for when evaluating whether or not speakers are a must have for serious gamers. The other bit is their description of NXT is wrong. I think they must have meant to say that they are not normal speakers that use cones that move in and out to create the disturbances in the air...rather than saying thats what they are. One last bit is the review complains about the lack of a volume control on the system yet the official specs say that the unit has a master volume control. Overall, they were very impressed with the system concluding that the sound quality rivaled their existing £500 home theater speakers.
  • Sirocco Crossfire
    Computer Games Online has posted their impressions of VideoLogic's Sirocco Crossfire. They found the sound quality to be good but still roughly comparable to the "greatest from Klipsch and Boston Acoustics" which I assume refer to the ProMedia and BA4800 respectively. If you read Mark's Sirocco Crossfire vs ProMedia comparison and his BA4800 review you know he doesn't think these 3 systems sounds roughly the same. One other thing worth noting is that the new satellites (grilles and mounting holes) mentioned for the US version in this review will be used for the European version as well as soon as VideoLogic sold through their current inventory of the old satellites.
  • MidiLand S4 7100 Speaker
    Broken Pixel has posted a very positive review of MidiLand's S4-7100 5.1 speaker system. The review implies that the system is as good as a hi-fi home theater setup and of course its not. What it does offer is good quality sound from the satellites, strong bass from subwoofer in most (but not all) configurations, great overall volume, great configuration flexibility and a good price (street price under $200). It's again worth noting that the system does not have its own decoder. It instead takes advantage of an external decoder like the ADS-2000 or a sound card and supporting software DVD player. The system is best and fully utilized with a sound card with 5.1 analog outputs like Best Data's Theatrix 5.1 (which uses software DVD decoding). I just finished trying the S4-7100 with a different FM801 board and drivers than what I based my original Best Data comments on with impressive DVD and game results when in 5.1 mode. In fact, if Turtle Beach's upcoming Santa Cruz sound card supports 5.1 analog output for games and movies (as it appears it will) it should be a good match with the S4-7100. Look for lots more details on the S4-7100 and Skywell Magic Sound Live when we post our reviews early this month.
  • Xitel MD Port AN1
    3DAI has posted a positive review of Xitel's USB based Mini Disc Port AN1, a device designed to give a high quality analog connection to Mini Disc recorders.
  • HP Jornada 545 Color PocketPC
    3D Accelerated has posted a review of the HP Jornada 545 Color PocketPC. Here's a snip on the MP3 capabilities:

    In addition to gaming, the Jornada 545 also has the ability to play MP3's. Using the built-in Media Player, we were able to compile playlists and listen to our favorite songs wherever we were. Additionally, since the Jornada has a button to shut off the display but keep MP3's (and other applications) running, we were able to conserve as much battery power as possible.

    The sound quality is truly amazing, and is comparable to the sound quality of any high end portable MP3 player (Rio 500, Nomad II, etc.). Treble tones were clear, while bass was booming.

    For more details, check out the full review.


Other sound news

  • Can you hear the difference between 24 and 16 bits?
    If you don't have a high quality professional soundcard that question may be tough to find an answer to but you Krüger's PCABX.com site will also let you see if you can hear the difference between 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11 and 10 bits. Here's the post he made recently in the Usenet newsgroup:

    I've been continuing to add new listening tests to the "technical" section of www.pcabx.com.

    Many will find these tests interesting and useful both for understanding technical controversies and also as a means to train their ears to be more sensitive by listening for the same kinds of changes in varying amounts.

    "24, 16, 15, 14, 12, 11, and 10 bit 44 KHz Samples"

    Besides shedding some light on the controversy over 24 bits, the samples with 16 bits or less contain progressively larger amounts of a fairly nasty kind of nonlinear distortion. Please don't assume that reliably detecting the "13" bit samples will be a slam dunk.

    "60 Hz Jitter applied at -20, -40, -60, and -80 dB"

    This is the jitter frequency I find most often in technical tests.
    Obviously, the digital signal is getting contaminated by the power supply.
    What is not so obvious is how difficult these samples are to detect. I hope to post samples with other jitter frequencies shortly.

    "Brick-Wall Low Pass Filter, Filter Points At 22, 18, 25, 12, 9, And 5 KHz"

    We've actually had one report of detection of the 18 KHz filter among the 100's of people who have tried it.

    "Level Mismatches of 10, 3, 1, 0.4 and 0.2 dB"

    10, 3, and 1 dB level mismatches should be a slam-dunk for you. They were for me,even using a very modest monitoring system featuring no-name PC speakers. Then there are those other two sets of samples...

    "Linkwitz-Riley Crossover Simulation, Crossover Points At 300 Hz And 3 KHz"

    We've had some positive and negative results reported from these tests. The finger snap seems to help. See how you do!

    You may also find the following follow up post interesting:

    > > Why do you need this? Have you ever been in a recording
    environment that
    > > has a 110 db dynamic range?
    > >
    > > This whole idea (24 bit 96 k s/s (by the way it is NOT HERTZ) is
    pure
    > > garbage.
    >
    > Which of course begs the question why do people prefer 24bit/96k over
    > 16bit/44.1k in double blind listening tests?

    Been there, done that, and they don't. This is one of the great mysteries of life, but AFAIK there are no refereed scientific papers or listening tests done under DBT conditions with adults and real-world music that show an audible degradation of the music due to 16/44 digital coding. Here is a long-standing test that supports that idea: http://www.oakland.edu/~djcarlst/abx_digi.htm

    If you go to http://www.pcabx.com/technical/index.htm you can find DBT's that you can download and do for yourself that illustrate this.
    For the "24, 16, 15, 14, 12, 11, and 10 bit 44 KHz Samples" , nobody has ever reported hearing the effects of degrading program material from 24 or 16 bits to 14 or 15 bits. For the "Brick-Wall Low Pass Filter, Filter Points At 22, 18, 25, 12, 9, And 5 KHz" , aftter 100's of downloads we have exactly 1 unconfirmed report of someone who could hear the application of a brick wall filter at 18 KHz.

    > (Given the general level of background noise in everyday life, though,
    > I'd agree up to a point about the necessity of 110dB dynamic range.)

    The facts I've gathered bear you out. I've been looking at the actual dynamic range of commercial recordings. The numbers are none to impressive. Many peak out below 60 dB, and the best I've ever seen was about 72 dB.

    That all said, the usual justification for production equipment with high resolution does stand logical scrutiny. Every time you process music, and producing music can involve processing it dozens of times, it degrades. If you want to deliver program material with a good solit 14 or 15 bit quality, you have to do all the processing to a higher standard. However, for delivery and reproduction of the end product by consumers, 16 bits is actually a bit or two of overkill.

    What this all means is that the more bits and higher sample rates of the upcoming DVD-audio discs are useless but in case of soundcards it could still make a difference. Worth noting that the current 16 bit consumer cards is clearly behind the quality of professional 16 bit soundcards.

  • Creative taps Internet investments to sell more cards
    That's the title of an article by Bloomberg that takes a look at how Creative's investments in other companies are used to sell more soundcards. The article also has some interesting bits on how soundcard sales are going and that Creative thinks their new PDE (Personal Digital Entertainment) division is where they expect most of the growth in the future. Here's a couple interesting snips:

    Take MediaRing.com Ltd, the world's No. 2 Internet phone operator, in which Creative has a 12 percent stake. Every time a call is made through the Singapore-based company, a message pops up to alert users if their computer's audio isn't enhanced by a Creative's sound card.

    I wonder if this is a new trend where a movie from Lucas Film will complain that your sound system isn't THX certified and music from Sony will let you know that your Player isn't made by Sony.

    Analysts expect the company's profit to rise to about US$127 million in the year ended May 31 from US$115 million a year ago. In its third quarter ended March, sales of its sound cards surged 47 percent to US$128.7 million, accounting for 39 percent of total sales. Quarterly profit surged fivefold to a record US$88.3 million.
    [snip]
    "It's creating a big barrier of entry for others--we're not just competing on a card-to-card basis anymore," Sim said. "If you want to make a sound card, you better do it the way Creative does: with support, Web sites, free content, free upgrades. Now, try to fight that!"

    Aureal tried and failed as we all know by now. Interesting to see if any other company will try to challenge Creative Labs to the extent Aureal did.

    New products such as Webcams and Nomad players are part of a new business segment called "Personal Digital Entertainment" that Creative created to ensure its survival as the sound card market matures. The group now contributes less than a tenth of Creative's sales.

    "Sound cards gave us a 10-year life span," Sim said. "The next 10 years, we'll focus on personal digital entertainment--we'll play and play well in this area."

    The star product in that segment is the Nomad JukeBox, an Internet music player which uses a disk drive to store up to 100 hours of music or the equivalent of 2,000 songs.
    [snip]
    "The JukeBox will be the next SoundBlaster," Sim said. "It's something that's branded and very hard to assemble."

    It will be interesting to see how well Creative Labs will succeed in this market considering they will now face competitors like Sony and Matsushita. That's something else than a small start up like Aureal.

  • SiS SiS730S chipset features 3D sound
    SiS last Thursday announced the SiS730S, the industry's first highly integrated single chip for AMD platform PCs with extensive features targeted at high performance PC market segment. One of these features Built-in 3D positional audio. No mention of what 3D sound engine it will use. For more about this chipset check out the press release
  • Boston Acoustics Introduces new Car Component Speakers
    Boston Acoustics last Thursday introduced the New Boston Rally®series car component speakers. There are 3 two-way systems in this new series: The RC620 features a 6.5`` woofer, while the RC520 and RC420 feature a 5'' and 4`` woofer respectively. All the systems are equipped with three different tweeter mounting kits for maximum installation flexibility. The RC620 and RC520 have an MSRP of $299 per pair. The RC420 has an MSRP of $279 per pair. These products will ship in June 2000. You can find more details in the press release
  • Polk Audio Announces New Line of After-Market Multimedia Loudspeakers
    Polk Audio has unveiled the second generation Active Media Reference (AMR) line of high performance self-amplified multimedia speakers. According to the announcement, the new AMR products are designed to bring high fidelity audio performance to home computers and any audio source that has a headphone jack, such as portable MP3 and CD players. Polk Audio’s first generation multimedia speakers earned critical acclaim for audio quality. The second-generation line features greatly improved performance, significantly lower prices and digital inputs (2 models). Two of the models are 5 piece, surround sound systems (no built in decoder) with the AMR-150 featuring a two way design on the front satellites and two digital inputs as well as analog inputs. Lots more details on each model, including pricing and availability can be found in their announcement.
  • MidiLand Announces the "MidiLand MK-01 Give-A-Way"
    MidiLand has announced the "MidiLand MK-01 Give-A-Way", an exclusive promotion that entitles all purchasers of the S4 MidiLand 7100 a free pair of MK-01, MidiLand’s multi-channel speaker system mounting kit, valued at over $49.95 was specially designed for use with satellite speaker systems. The unit is made of a highly durable material, Platallic™ ensuring the MK-01’s longevity and ability to hold up to 10 lbs of weight. The "MidiLand MK-01 Give-A-Way" will run from June 2000 till supplies of the MK-01 last. An estimated 10,000 pairs of MK-01 Mounting Kits will be given away. All S4 MidiLand 7100 systems leaving the MidiLand LA Headquarters warehouse will be specially marked with "MidiLand MK-01 Give-A-Way" stickers on their packaging. Inside the product packaging will be a registration card further outlining the details of the promotion. Consumers simply send in the completed registration card along with $4.95 for S&H ($10 for Alaska, Hawaii and Puerto Rico) and they will receive the MK-01 mounting kit free! For more details, check out the full press release. Look out for our reviews of both the MK-01 and the S4-7100 in the near future. 
  • Hanging CSW PCworks/Soundworks sats on the wall
    If you are looking for an easy and inexpensive way to hang the PCworks or other small speakers that don't have mounting holes you might want to check out this forum post from Efik. Remember, no registration is necessary to read or post in the forum.
  • Virtual audio for headphones
    Do you ever wonder how HRTFs work? There is an excellent article entitled Virtual audio for headphones written by Dr. Alastair Sibbald of Sensaura that will tell you all about it and then some. You might also want to check out the site that is hosting the article. It's called Headwize. HeadWize is a non-profit headphone resource site started by Chu Moy for the purpose of disseminating information about headphones and headphone listening.
  • THX Optimode allows you to Optimize for Individual DVD Movies
    A unique new DVD software feature from Lucasfilm THX® allows the performance of a home theatre system to be optimized for individual DVD releases. THX Optimode(TM) consists of a series of tests that make it easy for consumers to fine-tune the audio and video performance of their home components. The first DVD release to offer THX Optimode will be the Special Edition release of Fight Club on June 6. Other releases to come include T2 from Artisan and Anchor's Bay's Repoman, Hell Raiser and Hell Raiser II, with many more to follow. Check out the press release for more details
  • DivX editorial
    Salon.com has posted a review/editorial about DivX, what's often is refered to the MP3s of DVD movies.  The author of the article was not very impressed.
  • New software features universal support for music formats
    Interactive Objects last Thursday introduced iObjects Dadio(TM). Dadio is a digital audio operating system for portable digital music players that allows mp3 and other digital music file formats to be played interchangeably. This means that files stored in the popular mp3 format can play alongside files stored in other formats such as Microsoft's Windows Media or Dolby's AAC. I-Jam Multimedia will be the first to offer Dadio in its forthcoming Win-Jam player. Sort of odd choice considering they said it is the first to exclusively support the Microsoft Windows Media(tm) format. For more about this OS system check out the press release
  • Does MS Windows Media Format sound better than MP3?
    We all know that MS claims it does and was also backed up by a study performed by ZD Labs. In this study consumers found that 64 kbps Windows Media Format was better then MP3s encoded at 128 kbps. Important to note they used the Xing encoder which is not considered to a high quality encoder. Arny Krüger's new site pcabx.com recently kicked up a couple of test files where you can judge how the Windows Media Format compares to the Fraunhofer encoder, the one used by MusicMatch and also considered to the best one. Here's the post Arny Krüger made in the newsgroup recently

    There seems to be a lot of interest in improving the sound quality of MP3 files by going to better bit rates. Does it really work? OK, we know it can work, but what kind of sonic difference are we talking about anyhow?

    www.pcabx.com now has music files you can download and use to compare Musicmatch (Fraunhofer) encoding at 128 Kbps and 256 Kbps, along with brief summary technical reports on each one.

    Please see the following web pages:

    128 Kbps http://www.pcabx.com/product/mm4300058/index.htm

    256 Kbps http://www.pcabx.com/product/mm5000142/index.htm

    For a real laugh, have a listen at Microsoft's latest Windows Media Efforts.

    http://www.pcabx.com/product/wme4113920_wmpb1304/index.htm

    These files, coded at 128 Kbps are IMO a really good example of how not to displace MP3 as an audio file format for people who have even a slight interest in sound quality.

    Several striking things kinda leapt out at me when I was preparing these files. I use narrow clicks to separate the musical selections, and in some cases, the "Windows Media dynamic duo" simply made the
    clicks "go away". This effect is most pronounced in the "Finger Snaps" selection which is composed of 12 finger snaps. Its actually the same recording of a finger snap repeated 12 times. Well that's what it sounds like on the reference file and *every* other file at www.pcabx.com. But, 12 identical snaps is not what the "Windows Media dynamic duo" does. It pretty well creams the first snap in the series. So, after coding and decoding there is a kind of a thud followed by 11 snaps...

    The "Windows Media dynamic duo" also falls flat on its face with the "castanets" samples. Compare to the MusicMatch/Fraunhofer 128 Kbps samples to see how far MS still needs to go...

    I wish I was making this up or it was a technical error on my part!

    It's of course possible the difference would be significantly less or even in MS favour with other type of files. To make your own comparisons using your favourite music just download MusicMatch.

  • Mötley Crüe Praises Internet, Mocks Metallica
    On Yahoo they have an article about how Mötley Crüe unlike several other bands don't want to sue companies like Napster. Here's a snip

    "Mötley Crüe have always supported any outlet, Internet or otherwise, that allows us to connect to our fans," said bass player Nikki Sixx in a statement. "We have always allowed our fans to tape shows and exchange bootlegs, and the Internet is the perfect auditorium for this fan revolution."

    Madonna and Warner Bros. Records are less pleased with Napster and the Internet after they found out that the title track of the upcoming album, "Music," leaked onto the Web and Napster well in advance of its release date.

    A bit different take on Napster, RIAA and trading illegal MP3s is available on ZDNet. It's an article written by the independent Musician Stephen Walker who sees hard times ahead for independent artists unless MP3 swappers change their "evil ways".

  • Xitel Launches MD-Port DG1
    Xitel has launched a new addition to their line-up of Mini Disc oriented products. The MD-Port DG1 is similar to the MD-Port AN1 reviewed by 3DAI with the biggest difference being the DG1 uses an optical connection to the Mini Disc recorder where as the AN1 uses an analog connection. According to the info on Xitel's site, the DG1 also automatically inserts track marks where as the AN1 takes advantage the same feature via Music Match.
  • MP3.com Launches New Retail Music Division
    Capitalizing on what it sees as a tremendous opportunity for company growth, MP3.com, has launched a new business division to target the multi-million dollar retail music licensing market.

    MP3.com's Retail Music Division provides web-enabled, business-to-business music delivery solutions to grocery stores, fashion outlets, shopping malls, restaurants and other retail establishments. These establishments are able to select from over 424,000 songs and audio files from more than 67,000 artists at the MP3.com site. Subscribers can manage and modify their music selections anytime and anywhere utilizing an online private account page. If you want more details check out the full announcement

  • Cirrus Logic's Maverick Chosen for Win-Jam
    Cirrus Logic last Tuesday announced that its Maverick(tm) system-on-chip (SOC) Internet audio solution will be featured in the new Win-Jam Digital Audio Player from I-Jam Multimedia. The device is the first to exclusively support the Microsoft Windows Media(tm) format, which is great news for MS. Not sure why it's great news for I-Jam's customers though.

    The Win-Jam device, which Microsoft has been promoting by giving away one free device every day for the month of May, enables users to store twice as much CD-quality music as devices that only support MP3. The player is scheduled to be available in July. You can check out the press release for more details

  • Toshiba Selects Texas Instruments DSP For New Mobile Audio Player
    Toshiba and Texas Instruments last Tuesday announced it is using TI's low-power DSP to power Toshiba's new Mobile Audio Player, MEA110AS. The player is the world's first to offer a Secure Digital (SD) memory card slot supporting storage of copyrighted content. Using the Mobile Audio Player, consumers can download music content to 64MB of built-in flash memory or to 32MB or 64MB SD memory cards via the player's USB port.

    TI's TMS320C5000(TM) DSPs support AAC and MP3 formats, which are used in the Toshiba Mobile Audio Player. TI's programmable DSPs, which support all current and future compression formats, allow manufacturers to update features and functions with a simple software download, rather than by upgrading internal hardware. Additionally, TI's low power DSPs increase the battery life of Internet audio players and its small size enables manufacturers like Toshiba to design devices with extremely compact form factors.

  • Music Downloads will soon be a Multibillion-Dollar Business
    That's the prediction IDC makes in a recent report based on a recent survey where they found out that use of music downloads is by far the heaviest among individuals under 20 years old. More than 77% of respondents under 20 said someone in their household has downloaded songs off the Internet. No other age group exceeded 52% use of downloads. Additionally, among consumers who have downloaded songs, more than 47% of those under 20 said they or someone in their house owns a portable digital music player. This is nearly three times the use of the next highest group and indicates approximately one-third of Internet users under 20 own these music devices or live with someone who does. Based on these numbers IDC are sure music downloads will increase in importance over time. You can check out the press release for more details. Worth noting that soon is 5-10 years from now.
  • Gnutella & Napster
    Tech-Extreme has posted a short article about Gnutella and Napster. Both programs are mostly used to trade MP3s but work a bit differently. In case you don't remember Gnutella is the program Nullsoft introduced but later dumped, not surprisingly considering Nullsoft is owned by AOL that also owns Time Warner. Here's a taste:

    Gnutella allows the direct transfer of information from one user to another without having to go through a central server that can monitor the transactions. What this means is that instead of you logging on to a big server like Napster, you log on to another users computer. Though this process is slightly more difficult to learn and results in your downloading to be a lot slower, it makes the network a lot harder to shut down. Instead of just eliminating the central server in programs like Napster, you would have to eliminate every single computer on the Gnutella network.

  • Modern Humorist: Encyclopedia Brown and the Case of the Pirated MP3s
    ENCYCLOPEDIA BROWN and Sally Kimball, his junior detective partner and bodyguard, were getting ready to go to the Idaville music festival when a limousine pulled into Encyclopedia’s driveway.

    "Wow!" Sally said. "That car is so big, and so black!"

    Four men in tight, black leather pants and sleeveless T-shirts got out of the limousine. They had pale skin covered in tattoos, and one of them had bits of metal hanging from various parts of his face. Encyclopedia and Sally exchanged worried glances. They had never seen men their fathers' age wearing leather pants before.

    "Do not be frightened, young children, I am Lars Ulrich, powerhouse drummer for Metallica, and we are needing your help, Encyclopedia Brown." Metallica is a popular musical group known for blending traditional rock and roll with heavy metal while using more introspective and meaningful lyrics than most metal bands. "I am giving you a quarter."

    Encyclopedia accepted the coin and asked, "What can we do for you?"

    "Someone is stealing our music!" growled James Hetfield, rhythm guitar and lead vocals.

    That's just a small taste of what awaits you over at the Modern Humorist.

  • Never Mind the Manilow
    Never Mind the Manilow is the title of a new article just posted on BarrysWorld. In it they highlights some off the musical highlights (and lowlights) in gaming history. Here`s a snip:

    With a lot of the titles that I've had exposure to in my gaming life (I'm talking now about long before BarrysWorld was an itch in Teds pants or a nasty rash in DBs knickers) the music was nothing more than an annoying embellishment that was (if the option was available) turned off. To be honest with some titles it still is, and indeed some genres (hard core flight sims for one). But with some titles the game just wouldn't be the same without it. Some titles just shine through and you find that if you're denied the music the game just doesn't have the same appeal, it's those titles which have prompted this ramble.

  • Game Music Broadcast
    Our friend Jeff Atwood has started a new website called Game basement and their latest feature is 24/7 broadcast of game music. You can check out the broadcast info here and they are also looking for some feedback on your favourite game music.

 

For more news from last week check out our news archive.

Upcoming features at 3DsoundSurge

  • Altec Lansing's ATP3
  • DigiTheatre DTS
  • MidiLand S4 7100
  • A review of PowerDVD 2.55
  • Monsoon MM-1000
  • Turtle Beach Cancun

As always if you have any ideas for products we should review or features we should do, please let us know.

Previous "The week in review".

Subscribe to our 3D Audio Week in Review Newsletter

Enter your E-mail Address
Enter your First Name
Subscribe    Un-Subscribe

This information, your first name and email address, will not be used for
any other purpose, or made available to others for any reason what so ever.

dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)
3dss_small.gif (2549 bytes)All content, design and work is © 1999 - 3D Sound Surge . Design and Layout by Spyre of Future Games Network.
Please respect the copyrights of the articles and writers herein. All copyrights are enforced by 3DSS and Future Games Network
dot_yellowish.gif (35 bytes)