|
|
| Sound News | Press
Releases | Archives | Week In
Review | Editorials
| Articles | |
|
![]() |
|
||||
|
|||||
Sound Blaster Live! Platinum - America's Edition - Mark Muschett- Last updated February 12, 2001
Introduction: Update: Creative Labs has now replaced this card with the
new Live Platinum 5.1. We suggest you check out our Live!Platinum 5.1 review or our Live reference review for our latest impressions of the
Live. The Live reference review covers all Live cards. That strangle hold on the retail PC audio market has been loosening over the past few years with challenges coming from companies like Turtle Beach and Gravis (remember the Ultrasound?). However, most of these were coming at Creative on Creatives own turf. That is they were limited to competing with products that had to claim Sound Blaster compatibility but with superior MIDI performance as their claim to fame. That all changed in 1997 when Diamond introduced the original DSP based Monster Sound which was the first retail sound card to use the PCI bus. This cards weak point was Sound Blaster compatibility, but its support of A3D 1.x and DS3D (in hardware via Direct X5) caught the imagination of both the gaming press and the buying public just as the Windows 95 and DirectX had started to become more popular and reduce the importance of DOS SB compatibility. Creatives state of the art card at the time was the venerable Sound Blaster AWE 64. The Monster Sound retail success in North America and wide support in the gaming press was a big wake up call to Creative. Ensoniq was also in the market with the AudioPCI which at the time had better SB compatibility than the Monster Sound but no A3D support. Creative saw a good thing in Ensoniqs DOS compatibility mode and bought the company. Aureal moved beyond providing drivers and algorithms to hardware partners and entered the chip and board market with the now widely adopted Vortex 1 chip. It was not until Comdex 97 that Creative started to hit the press with their upcoming 10K1 chip and Sound Blaster Live Product which was eventually launched in August of 1998. Creative has a bit different spin to the sequence of events and point out that with the R&D time needed to develop the 10K1, they were actually ahead of the game. Thats not how my eyes see it but regardless of the chicken and egg discussion by the time the Live was announced they clearly had lost their strangle hold on the retail PC sound market. This meant that it was going to be extremely important to the company that the Live be a big success, especially since Aureal was also coming to market just a couple of months later with their own new Vortex 2 board along with their then new A3D 2.0 API. To help make the Live special, Creative worked to develop a new extension to Direct Sound 3D called Environmental Audio Extensions (EAX). Over a year after the launch of the Live! the 10K1, the Live! and the Live!Value can be considered an unqualified success. Creative has been responsive to the needs of their customers with enhancements to the software through their innovative marketing mechanism called Live!Ware. Enhancements to the gaming aspect of the card included a quick bump of the 3D accelerated streams from 8 to 32, connection options to home theater systems and from our perspective, better 3D audio support. So why release a new product line based on the same 10K1 chip? The cynic would say grabbing our money twice for the same product would really increase profit margins, as the R&D costs are pretty low! However, the truth is that no matter how good a product is, there are always little things that can be done to make it better. Creative has listened to the needs and wants of gamers, musicians, and music lovers alike and reengineered the software bundles and connectivity of a whole new 10K1 based Live!. In the Americas that means one package, the SB Live MP3+, for the digital music lovers, another, the SB Live X-Gamer, for you guessed it, gamers with an excellent game bundle and yet another higher end card just bristling with connections via the card itself and the LiveDrive which gives access to connections on the front of the computer. This is the Live! card for the person who wants it all - games, MP3 features, MIDI editing and more. In Europe, Creative has taken a similar tactic but combined some aspects of the MP3+ and X-Gamer into the Live! Player 1024 and added even more connectivity to the Live! Platinum in the form of the Live!Drive II. In this review we are going to take a close look at the Americas version of the Sound Blaster Live! Platinum. Technical Overview: As noted above, just like the previous line of Sound Blaster Live! line of cards, the new Sound Blaster Live! Platinum uses the powerful EMU 10K1 sound processor. Whats changed is the card now has greater connectivity and great software enhancements which we will note where its new. First the hardware. The following is a list of the key features of all the new Sound Blaster Live! cards:
Live!Drive
I have already heard complaints from people who say the connections are better off on the back, but personally I like them just where they are with easy access. The one omission out of the box is the LiveDrive does not have optical connections. Not sure why Creative went with the LiveDrive II, which has optical in and out in Europe but not North America, but I suspect it has something to do with the greater popularity of MiniDisc players. Most MiniDisc players and some AC3 amps use the TOS Link input, some use the COAX input and others actually have both. Its the same for home theater speakers as some use optical, some use COAX and some use both. Cambridge Soundworks uses a coax connector so if you want to connect the Live Platinum to Cambridge Soundworks DeskTop Theater 5.1 system there wont be a problem. However, if optical out is important to you and you are looking at the Americas version of the Platinum then you will have to upgrade to the Digital Output Module that Creative will offer as a separate upgrade. If you use that Module with their upcoming digital I/O board it will also offer optical in. The Live!Drive II will also be upgrade option that for around $150 will add an additional line in as well as the optical in and outs to what you already find on the Live!Drive I. The actual optional Digital Output Module will connect to the external digital mini-jack on the Live! card itself. The card also has the same digital connector as the original full version of the Live but most likely you will be using this for the Live!Drive. However, the LiveDrive itself has an internal digital expansion connector that is the same as the connector found on the cards so you can check out add on boards from Hoontech with optical in and out as well as the possible optical I/O board from Creative. Without even getting into the feature of the Live!Drive, one nice thing is you no longer have to lose a slot in your PC to get the enhanced connectivity and its accessed from the front of the PC. Alternatively, some people will not want to or have the option of giving up a 5 ¼ bay and using a power connector (even though it comes with a splitter). Personally, I like it at the front but would recommend that you mount it in the bottom drive bay so the cords hanging down dont get in the way of your CD or DVD drive doors. The headphone jack is also a very nice feature for night-time use and even offers an auto speaker mute feature (which can be disabled). However, it would have been a lot nicer if it had been amplified to get a bit more volume to the headphones. A couple other points of note about the SPDIF out on the Live and Live!Drive. The SPDIF input signal will always be re-sampled to the SB Live internal 48 kHz. Even if you feed the SPDIF input with a 48 kHz signal, it still wouldn't be synchronized with the SB Live's internal 48 kHz, so it has to be re-sampled. That's why EMU10K1-based cards will never have 1:1 SPDIF recording unless they implement some kind of synchronization or perhaps an option to bypass the EMU10K1. The other thing to note is the SPDIF output is also fixed to 48 kHz.
|
Sound Card Reviews Hurricane Extreme Initial Review SoundBlaster Live! reference review SoundBlaster Live! Platinum 5.1 European Edition SoundBlaster Live! Platinum 5.1 America's Edition Sound Blaster Live! Player 5.1 Sound Blaster Live! X-Gamer 5.1 Hoontech SoundTrack Digital-XG Boostaroo Headphone Amplifier / Splitter Sound Blaster Live!Drive I and II Sound Blaster Creative Digital I/O 2 |
|